Electrical Surge in a Co-ownership: Hydro-Québec and Insurance
An electrical surge can burn out appliances, damage panels and paralyse essential systems (elevators, ventilation). In divided co-ownerships, responsibility may be shared among Hydro-Québec, the syndicate’s insurance, co-owners’ insurance and, sometimes, contractors. Wondering who pays? This guide, updated on August 25, 2026, explains the steps, remedies and preventive measures, while keeping the realities faced by boards and managers in mind.
We use the expression “electrical surge co-ownership Hydro-Québec insurance” to cover all situations: an event originating from the grid, lightning, common equipment or a private appliance. Below, you will find concrete scenarios, the policies to activate and best practices to record in the minutes and the maintenance logbook / EUC.
Electrical surges: understanding the risk in a condo building
An electrical surge is a brief but significant increase in voltage. It may result from:
- An incident on Hydro-Québec’s grid (switching, upstream equipment failure);
- Lightning or an atmospheric phenomenon;
- An internal fault: short circuit, motor start-up of common equipment (pump, elevator), transformer or poorly maintained panel;
- A non-compliant installation or a defective private appliance.
In a co-ownership, distinguish between:
- Common portions (main panels, risers, electrical rooms, elevators);
- Limited common portions (e.g., garage outlets);
- Private portions (appliances and outlets in the units).
This mapping, recorded in your declaration of co-ownership and specified in the building’s regulations, guides the allocation of costs. The maintenance logbook / EUC should include an “electrical” section: inspection dates, tightening of connections, surge protector testing, replacement of circuit breakers and work performed by a qualified contractor.
Hydro-Québec: potential liability and remedies
Hydro-Québec operates the distribution grid. If the surge clearly resulted from a grid incident, a claim may be considered. In practice, liability is assessed under ordinary law (fault, damage, causal connection; see section 1457 of the C.C.Q., Civil Code of Québec). The Hydro-Québec Act governs the activities of the Crown corporation, but does not create automatic compensation for every power failure.
Practical advice for the board:
- Document everything: date/time, measured voltage increases (if a recorder was used), affected appliances, invoice from a master electrician and photos;
- Promptly retain an electrical contractor holding a licence (RBQ) to diagnose the cause and secure the premises;
- Notify your insurers without delay (the syndicate and the co-owners);
- If there are serious indications that the upstream grid is responsible, submit a formal claim supported by an expert report. The matter should be authorized by a board resolution and recorded in the minutes; depending on its scope, ratify it at the AGM.
On the ground, even when a surge is linked to the grid, initial compensation most often comes from insurers (the syndicate and co-owners). Insurers may then exercise subrogation rights, if necessary, against a potentially liable third party.
Insurance: who compensates what?
The syndicate must insure the building (common portions and private portions, excluding unit improvements, according to the declaration of co-ownership), while each co-owner insures their movable property, improvements and civil liability. The following principles, often applied in practice and by the RGCQ, help provide guidance:
- Syndicate insurance: material damage to common portions and “original” private portions (according to the defined initial condition), less the deductible;
- Unit insurance (co-owner): improvements, contents, additional living expenses and, sometimes, a contribution to the syndicate’s deductible if the declaration of co-ownership and policy provide for it;
- Civil liability (syndicate or co-owner): where fault is established (inadequate maintenance, non-compliant work, etc.).
Useful references include sections 1073 et seq. of the C.C.Q. concerning syndicate insurance, the allocation of deductibles and claims between co-owners and the syndicate (see the Civil Code of Québec). The RGCQ publishes practical guides on this subject (RGCQ).
Deductible and allocation under the declaration of co-ownership
- The syndicate’s policy deductible remains a common expense, unless the declaration of co-ownership provides otherwise or the law/building regulations provide for recharging it when a co-owner caused the claim.
- The AGM may adopt procedural clarifications, but avoid rules that conflict with the C.C.Q. or the declaration of co-ownership.
- Inform co-owners that their home insurance often includes “condo fees/syndicate deductible” coverage; recommend that they discuss it with their broker.
For operational support during a claim, see the relevant sections of our services: operations management and administrative management.
Who pays? 6 common scenarios and guidelines
The following table provides an overview. Each case requires a factual analysis; rely on expert reports and your insurers.
| Scenario | Probable cause | Likely payer | Insurance involved | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1) Upstream grid voltage spike | Distribution incident | Compensation by insurers (syndicate/units), followed by a possible claim against a third party | Syndicate policy + unit policies | Causation must be established; a technical file is useful for any claim |
| 2) Lightning | External phenomenon | Insurers (syndicate/co-owners) according to the damage | Syndicate policy + unit policies | SPD surge protectors reduce the extent of the damage |
| 3) Poorly maintained common panel | Inadequate maintenance | Syndicate (common portions) and, depending on the case, civil liability | Syndicate policy (property) + civil liability | The maintenance logbook/EUC and invoices affect the assessment of fault |
| 4) Work performed by an unlicensed electrician | Non-compliance | The party that retained the contractor; potential liability | Civil liability of the party at fault | Always require a valid RBQ licence |
| 5) Defective private appliance (e.g., oven) | Equipment failure | The co-owner concerned | Unit policy (property/civil liability) | It may affect the common circuit: isolate it and have it inspected |
| 6) Overloaded garage outlet (limited common portion) | Improper use / overload | Depending on the source (user, syndicate) | Syndicate policy and/or user’s civil liability | Add signage and GFCI/AFCI circuit breakers as needed |
For all electrical work, comply with the Construction Code, Chapter V – Electricity (see RBQ – Chapter V).
Prevent, respond and document: the board’s roadmap
When an electrical surge occurs:
- Secure the premises: shut off the power if necessary and restrict access to electrical rooms.
- Call a master electrician holding an RBQ licence to diagnose the problem and stabilize the situation.
- Preserve evidence: photos, damaged parts, reports, invoices and serial numbers.
- Immediately notify the insurers (the syndicate, followed by notice to co-owners for their unit policies).
- If the upstream grid is suspected, prepare a documented formal claim.
- Communicate: send a newsletter to co-owners and record the details in the board’s minutes.
- Next AGM: ratify major decisions and adopt preventive measures.
Prevention (cost-effective when funded through the contingency fund and maintenance budget):
- Install surge protectors (SPDs) at the service entrance and at critical panels; plan their maintenance in the maintenance logbook / EUC;
- Periodically tighten terminal blocks, perform thermography on panels and replace worn circuit breakers;
- Ensure appropriate protection and calibration for elevators, pumps, ventilation systems and electric vehicle charging stations;
- Adopt rules of use in the building regulations (garage outlets, extension cords and high-load appliances);
- Check grounding, equipotential bonding and work compliance (RBQ);
- Audit insurance coverage: deductibles, “equipment breakdown” and “condo fees” endorsements.
Need help structuring these processes? See our packages and overview of our services. Also consult our blog for additional resources.
Frequently asked questions (FAQ)
- Does Hydro-Québec have to compensate for every electrical surge? No. A surge attributable to the grid does not automatically result in compensation. Liability is governed by ordinary law (section 1457 of the C.C.Q.). Insurers often compensate first and then, where appropriate, pursue a claim against a third party. Refer to the Civil Code of Québec and, for the Crown corporation’s legal framework, the Hydro-Québec Act.
- Is a surge protector mandatory? The Construction Code, Chapter V – Electricity, sets out the applicable requirements. Depending on the use and configuration, installing surge protection devices (SPDs) is strongly recommended and may sometimes be required by the design. See the RBQ and consult a master electrician.
- Who pays the syndicate’s deductible? By default, the deductible is a common expense. However, the declaration of co-ownership and the regulations may provide for recharging it to the co-owner who caused the claim, where permitted by law. Check your documents and ask your insurer for advice.
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice. For your situation, consult a lawyer or notary.
Do you manage a co-ownership in Québec? Discover our packages or contact us to assess your needs.
