Concierge or Outsourced Maintenance in a Co-ownership
Choosing between a concierge and outsourced maintenance directly affects the quality, continuity and cost of operations. In a divided co-ownership, this decision also involves staff supervision, contracts and emergency management.
The building’s size is not enough to make the decision. The board of directors must consider the frequency of tasks, equipment, co-owners’ expectations and its ability to follow up. A hybrid arrangement may also be more suitable than choosing an entirely in-house or outsourced model.
Here is how to compare the options without confusing daily presence, technical expertise and the syndicate’s decision-making responsibility.
What is the difference between a concierge and an outsourced service?
A concierge is generally assigned to the building on a regular basis. Depending on the mandate, they may handle routine cleaning, take out waste and recyclable materials, inspect common portions and report an issue. Their knowledge of the premises often makes it easier to quickly detect damage, a breakdown or unusual behaviour.
However, the word “concierge” does not by itself define the person’s status. They may be an employee of the syndicate, an employee of a company or a self-employed worker. The contract and the actual nature of the relationship must be reviewed before establishing administrative, tax and insurance obligations.
Outsourced maintenance is instead based on a company being retained for specified tasks and frequencies. The provider normally manages staff assignments and replacements. The syndicate nevertheless remains responsible for defining the mandate, monitoring quality and authorizing expenses.
Neither a concierge nor a maintenance company automatically replaces a specialized contractor. Regulated work must be entrusted to the appropriate professionals. The board can consult the Régie du bâtiment du Québec and verify the required licence before awarding certain contracts.
What criteria should the board evaluate?
The first criterion concerns the actual workload. A building with several entrances, a garage, elevators or outdoor spaces requires more frequent visits. The board should prepare a weekly, monthly and seasonal task list rather than rely on a general estimate.
Service continuity also matters. A regular concierge knows the building’s specific features, but their absence can create an operational gap. An outsourced company often has replacement capacity, although the substitute may not know the premises as well.
The board should then assess its ability to supervise. Direct employment involves schedules, documentation, replacements and administrative follow-up, among other things. Outsourcing reduces certain tasks but still requires someone responsible for verifying visits and documenting discrepancies.
Technical needs must remain separate from general maintenance. A visual inspection is not a repair, and reporting a leak does not constitute a diagnosis. For example, a condo roof leak may require a professional inspection and a decision on how to allocate the costs.
Finally, the budget must include more than the monthly invoice. Equipment, products, insurance, administration, replacements and the management of unforeseen events must also be considered. These expenses form part of the common expenses and may affect the contributions adopted by the syndicate.
Comparing the two maintenance models
The following table summarizes the main elements to review. It should be adapted to the declaration of co-ownership, the building’s regulations and the characteristics of the common portions.
| Criterion | Concierge assigned to the building | Outsourced maintenance |
|---|---|---|
| Presence | Regular and often predictable | According to the visits scheduled in the contract |
| Knowledge of the building | Generally becomes more in-depth over time | Varies depending on staff stability |
| Replacement | Must be arranged according to the person’s status and the agreement | Often handled by the provider |
| Supervision | Daily follow-up and administrative management are possible | Contract and quality control |
| Specialized expertise | Limited to the mandate and the person’s skills | Possible access to several resources |
| Cost predictability | Depends on status, hours and equipment | Depends on the scope and contractual exclusions |
The comparison should not be limited to the hourly rate. A less expensive quote may exclude supplies, emergencies or certain seasonal tasks. Conversely, a daily presence may exceed the needs of a small co-ownership.
An annual analysis makes it possible to compare the service received with the budget adopted at the AGM. The board can record its assessment and decision in minutes, particularly when the change significantly affects the common expenses.
How should the mandate be structured and quality controlled?
The mandate should include a precise description of the tasks. It may cover lobbies, corridors, stairways, common rooms, garages and outdoor areas. It should also specify excluded areas, including private portions, which generally do not fall within the syndicate’s routine maintenance responsibilities.
A frequency schedule prevents unclear expectations. It can distinguish between daily, weekly, monthly and seasonal tasks. The contract should also indicate the reporting procedure, emergency contact information, expected response times and the process for authorizing additional expenses.
The board benefits from using simple evidence: visit logs, dated photos, incident reports and checklists. These documents facilitate complaint follow-up and comparison between the work requested and the work completed. They can also contribute to the maintenance logbook and the planning of future interventions.
The Civil Code of Québec entrusts the syndicate with preserving the immovable and administering the common portions, notably under article 1039 C.C.Q. Outsourcing a task therefore does not relieve the board of its duty to supervise and make decisions.
To structure inspections and follow-up, the board can link the mandate to the co-ownership maintenance logbook. The contingency fund study also helps plan major replacements, which must not be confused with cleaning or minor checks.
Which model is best for your co-ownership?
A regular concierge may be appropriate when the building requires frequent presence, numerous inspections and detailed knowledge of its equipment. However, this model requires a clear structure and a realistic solution for absences. The board must also avoid gradually expanding the mandate without adjusting the responsibilities.
Outsourced maintenance is often suitable when tasks are standardized and can be grouped into scheduled visits. It generally facilitates replacements and access to several resources. Its success nevertheless depends on precise specifications, quality indicators and a clearly identified contact person.
A hybrid arrangement is often useful. A concierge or attendant can conduct regular rounds, while specialized companies handle systems, repairs and work requiring a licence. The RGCQ also offers resources on governance and best practices in co-ownership.
A manager can centralize requests, solicit quotes and coordinate providers. multiRent’s operations management services are designed for this coordination in buildings with 5 to 200 units in Montréal, on the South Shore and on the North Shore. multiRent does not hold an RBQ licence and does not perform any work; instead, it coordinates licensed subcontractors when the nature of the mandate requires it.
Before making a decision, the board should compare annual scenarios on an equivalent basis. Each scenario must include the tasks, frequencies, exclusions, replacements and supervision time. This method makes the decision more transparent for co-owners and facilitates its review in the next budget.
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice. For your situation, consult a lawyer or notary.
Do you manage a co-ownership in Québec? View our rates or contact us to assess your needs.
