Conflict Between the Declaration and Co-ownership Regulations
A conflict between the declaration and co-ownership regulations can complicate an otherwise routine decision. The issue often involves animals, renovations, parking, noise or the use of common portions. In a divided co-ownership, the answer depends on the exact nature of the documents and the rules set out in the Civil Code of Québec.
The term “regulation” can sometimes be confusing. The building regulations normally form part of the declaration of co-ownership, also known as the DCV. A syndicate may also adopt amendments, administrative policies or resolutions after the declaration has been published.
These documents do not all have the same scope. Before imposing a penalty or refusing a request, the board of directors must therefore trace the origin of the rule in question.
The declaration of co-ownership contains three parts
Under the Civil Code of Québec, the declaration of co-ownership includes the constituting act, the building regulations and the description of the fractions. These three parts form a whole, but they serve distinct purposes.
The constituting act defines, among other things, the destination of the building, the private portions and the common portions. It also specifies voting rights, the relative value of the fractions and certain responsibilities of the syndicate. Its structural provisions generally cannot be circumvented by a simple resolution of the board.
The building regulations instead govern the enjoyment, use and maintenance of the spaces. They may address noise, animals, moving, balconies or access to a swimming pool. They also include rules relating to the day-to-day administration of the co-ownership.
Finally, the description of the fractions identifies the fractions, real rights and cadastral numbers. It notably makes it possible to distinguish the common portions from the private portions. This distinction becomes decisive when a co-owner wishes to carry out work.
The RGCQ also publishes resources to help directors better understand these documents. They usefully supplement a review of the DCV, without replacing a tailored legal opinion.
Which document prevails in the event of a conflict?
The first rule is to comply with applicable legislation. A clause in the declaration or a regulation that is incompatible with a mandatory provision of the Civil Code may be unenforceable. The age of a clause is therefore not enough to confirm its validity.
Within the DCV, the constituting act establishes the fundamental framework of the co-ownership. The building regulations must be interpreted consistently with this framework. A rule governing use should not indirectly modify the destination of the building or the fundamental rights attached to the fractions.
A validly adopted amendment may, however, replace a previous provision dealing with the same subject. The authority of the decision-making body, the applicable majority and the preservation or publication formalities must be verified.
| Document or decision | Main function | Point to verify in the event of a conflict |
|---|---|---|
| Legislation and Civil Code of Québec | Mandatory legal framework | Mandatory nature of the provision |
| Constituting act of the co-ownership | Structure, destination and fundamental rights | Validly adopted and published amendment |
| Building regulations | Use, enjoyment, maintenance and administration | Compatibility with the constituting act |
| Amendment filed in the syndicate’s register | Update to the regulations | Adoption, date and proof of filing |
| Board resolution or internal policy | Day-to-day application and management | Board’s actual authority and compliance with the DCV |
An internal policy does not take priority simply because it is more recent. For example, the board may regulate the reservation of a common room. It cannot remove a right provided for in the declaration without following the applicable amendment process.
The role of the date and formalities
The adoption date helps determine which version was in effect when an event occurred. It does not, however, settle everything. A recent decision adopted by the wrong body remains open to challenge.
Amendments to the constituting act or the description of the fractions normally require more extensive formalities. Depending on their nature, a notarized deed and publication in the land register may be required. Amendments to the building regulations must notably be recorded in the register kept by the syndicate to become enforceable against others in accordance with the applicable rules.
Minutes of an AGM constitute proof of the decision made. They do not automatically replace the amendment deed, its filing or its publication. The syndicate must retain the resolution, the voting results and the consolidated version of the document.
How to resolve a document conflict
The board should avoid an improvised interpretation during a meeting or in an email exchange. A documented process reduces contradictory decisions and facilitates communications with co-owners.
- Define the dispute precisely. The conduct, work or right being challenged must be identified, without reducing the issue to a personal disagreement.
- Gather all versions. The published declaration, its amendments, the register, the minutes and the relevant resolutions must be compared.
- Classify each provision. The board must determine whether the rule comes from the constituting act, the regulations or an administrative policy.
- Verify the decision-making authority. A board resolution cannot exceed the powers granted by the law and the DCV.
- Check the majorities and formalities. Articles 1096 to 1098 C.C.Q. provide for different majorities depending on the decision being considered.
- Record the analysis. The minutes should set out the decision, its reasons and the documents reviewed, without disclosing a confidential legal opinion.
- Obtain professional advice if necessary. A notary or lawyer practising in co-ownership law can assess the validity and enforceability of a clause.
Consulting the OACIQ can also clarify documentary obligations when selling a condo. An ambiguous rule or incomplete register may lead to questions during a transaction.
Example involving renovations
Suppose that a regulation authorizes certain floor coverings in a private portion. A recent board policy then requires different soundproofing, without a formal amendment to the DCV. The policy may specify a procedure or reasonable technical evidence, but it cannot necessarily abolish the existing authorization.
The board must then examine the destination of the building, the acoustic standards provided for and the powers granted by the declaration. It must also determine whether the work affects a common portion, even if it is located inside the condo. When the work relates to construction, the directory and information provided by the Régie du bâtiment du Québec may help verify the applicable obligations.
Preventing conflicts in syndicate management
A consolidated version of the declaration makes it easier to consult, but it must clearly distinguish the published text from amendments to the regulations. Each change should indicate its adoption date, filing date and the decision-making body involved.
The syndicate also benefits from maintaining a structured register. This includes the DCV, amendments, minutes, contracts, financial statements, maintenance logbook and contingency fund studies. Consistent document management supports both the board and co-owners.
Before each AGM, directors should verify whether a proposal actually changes a right. A decision presented as a simple procedure may sometimes affect the destination or use of a fraction. The voting threshold and formalities must then be reassessed.
multiRent’s administrative management services can support meeting preparation, record-keeping and resolution follow-up. This organization does not replace legal advice, but it helps the syndicate maintain a clear documentary record.
Frequently asked questions
Can the board adopt a new regulation on its own?
The board may take measures that fall within its management powers and apply existing rules. However, it cannot amend a provision on its own when the law or the DCV requires a vote by the co-owners. The actual content of the decision matters more than its title.
Does an old regulation remain valid?
It may remain applicable if it has not been replaced and complies with current mandatory provisions. Its age does not, however, establish either its validity or its enforceability. Amendments published or filed since its adoption must be verified.
Can a co-owner challenge an inconsistent rule?
Yes, depending on the circumstances. The co-owner should request the applicable text, the adoption resolution and the syndicate’s reasons. Legal advice can then help assess the remedies, time limits and advisability of mediation.
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice. For your situation, consult a lawyer or notary.
Do you manage a co-ownership in Quebec? Discover our plans or contact us to assess your needs.
