The President’s Casting Vote in a Quebec Co-ownership
A tie vote can quickly paralyze an important decision in a divided co-ownership. Can the president of the syndicate vote a second time to break the tie? The answer depends primarily on the body holding the vote: the board of directors or the meeting of co-owners.
Being president does not automatically confer a casting vote. The Civil Code of Québec, the declaration of co-ownership and the rules applicable to the meeting must be reviewed. A decision based on an incorrect interpretation could be challenged.
Does the president automatically have a casting vote?
No. The president usually leads the discussion, ensures that the agenda is followed and announces the voting results. These duties, on their own, do not give the president an additional vote.
A casting vote is distinct from an ordinary vote. It allows the president to break a tie only when a valid rule provides for it. The first step is therefore to determine whether the vote is being held by the board of directors or at a meeting of co-owners.
The Civil Code of Québec governs these two bodies differently. The articles dealing with legal persons and co-ownership must be read together with the declaration of co-ownership. The building’s by-laws may also specify meeting procedures, subject to the mandatory provisions of the law.
| Situation | President’s ordinary vote | Casting vote | Usual consequence of a tie |
|---|---|---|---|
| Board of directors | One vote as a director | Possible only if an applicable text validly provides for it | The motion does not obtain a majority and generally fails |
| Meeting of co-owners | According to the votes attached to the co-owner’s fraction or to a valid proxy | No automatic right; any clause must be examined carefully | The resolution does not reach the required majority |
| Non-co-owner chairing a meeting | No personal vote | No automatic vote | Chairs the meeting without participating in the outcome |
At a meeting, the president does not receive an additional vote
At a meeting, the right to vote belongs to the co-owners. The number of votes is generally proportional to the relative value of each fraction, in accordance with section 1090 C.C.Q. A valid proxy may also allow a person to exercise the votes of a represented co-owner.
The meeting chair may therefore vote if they are themselves a co-owner or proxyholder. They then exercise the votes that belong to them or that have been entrusted to them, without receiving an additional vote because of their position. If they are neither a co-owner nor a proxyholder, they normally chair the meeting without voting.
Resolutions must obtain the applicable majority based on their nature. Sections 1096 to 1098 C.C.Q. provide for different thresholds, particularly for certain important amendments. A tie is not a majority; the resolution is therefore generally rejected.
A provision in the declaration of co-ownership granting the meeting chair a decisive vote warrants legal analysis. It cannot be used to circumvent voting rights or the majorities imposed by the Civil Code. The RGCQ also provides general information on governance and meeting practices.
The president should clearly announce the result without treating a tie as adoption. To prepare for an AGM or a special meeting, structured administrative management facilitates sending notices, compiling proxies and preserving decisions.
At the board level, the declaration of co-ownership is decisive
Board of directors decisions are normally made by a majority of the directors’ votes, under section 336 C.C.Q. Each director generally has one vote. The board president therefore does not automatically have two votes.
The declaration of co-ownership, particularly the building’s by-laws, may govern the board’s composition and decision-making procedures. Some declarations expressly provide for a casting vote in the event of a tie. Before using it, the syndicate should verify the wording, scope and compatibility with mandatory rules.
In the absence of a valid provision, a tie generally means that the motion did not obtain a majority. It should be considered rejected rather than arbitrarily placed in the column of adopted decisions. The board may resume the discussion at a later meeting or reword the motion.
Quorum must also be confirmed before any vote. A casting vote does not correct an absence of quorum and does not replace the vote of an absent director. Nor does it allow the president to disregard their obligations in a conflict-of-interest situation, including those arising from section 324 C.C.Q.
An old or ambiguous declaration, or one made up of several amending instruments, can complicate the analysis. The article on conflicts between the declaration and the co-ownership by-laws explains how to approach documents that appear contradictory.
How to properly handle a tie vote
The president and secretary should avoid improvising a rule during the meeting. An established procedure protects the legitimacy of the decision and reduces the risk of disputes between co-owners.
Here are the recommended checks to complete before announcing the result:
- Determine whether the decision falls under the board of directors or the meeting of co-owners.
- Confirm the quorum and the identity of the people authorized to vote.
- Verify the proxies and the number of votes attached to the fractions.
- Identify the majority required by the Civil Code and the declaration of co-ownership.
- Look for any clause expressly granting the president a casting vote.
- Record the exact result, abstentions and tie in the minutes.
The minutes should state the wording of the resolution and the voting result. If a casting vote is used, it is prudent to mention the provision authorizing it. This record allows directors, co-owners and consulted professionals to understand the decision.
An irregular resolution may sometimes be the subject of an application for judicial annulment. Section 1103 C.C.Q. notably provides a remedy against certain meeting decisions, with a time limit requiring a prompt response. The syndicate should consult a lawyer as soon as a serious challenge is announced.
The OACIQ also emphasizes the importance of the syndicate’s documents during a real estate transaction. Clear minutes help the parties understand decisions, assessments and governance issues. They also make it easier to provide consistent information when a condo is sold.
Frequently asked questions about casting votes
Can the president vote once and then break the tie?
At the board level, this mechanism is possible only if a valid provision grants the president a casting vote. At a meeting, the president exercises their own votes or those entrusted by proxy, but their position does not automatically create a second vote.
Does a tie mean that the resolution is deferred?
No. Generally speaking, a resolution that does not obtain the required majority is rejected. A new motion may be presented later, provided that the agenda, notice requirements and powers of the body concerned are respected.
Can the board amend its by-laws to create a casting vote?
The declaration of co-ownership and the authority responsible for amending the building’s by-laws must first be reviewed. The board should not assume that it can grant itself such a power by simple resolution. Legal advice is recommended before making any amendment affecting the balance of votes.
To avoid other procedural difficulties, the syndicate can also review the rules for calling a meeting when the board refuses. Good governance rests on rules that are known before a disagreement arises.
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a lawyer or notary for your situation.
Do you manage a co-ownership in Quebec? View our rates or contact us to assess your needs.
