Comparing Condo Management Proposals
Comparing a condo management proposal involves more than comparing two monthly fees. The proposed responsibilities, exclusions, financial controls and transition terms can vary considerably. A less expensive offer may therefore leave several tasks to the board of directors.
In a divided co-ownership, the board remains responsible for administering the syndicate, even when it delegates routine activities. It must choose an arrangement suited to the building’s size, risks and the availability of its directors. The following method makes it possible to assess proposals on a comparable basis.
Define your needs before requesting a proposal
The syndicate should prepare a brief profile of the building before contacting management companies. Consistent information helps each candidate assess the mandate according to the same parameters. It also reduces the number of reservations and additional charges discovered after signing.
The information provided should include:
- the number of units, buildings and parking spaces;
- the common equipment, such as elevators, the pool or access systems;
- the annual budget, common expenses and special assessments currently in effect;
- the desired frequency of visits and board meetings;
- the condition of the maintenance logbook and contingency fund study;
- any insurance claims, major projects or active disputes;
- the tasks the directors wish to retain.
The board should also provide a list of expected deliverables. This may cover the budget, financial statements, assessment notices, the AGM, the minutes and supplier follow-up. The declaration of co-ownership should also be reviewed, since it may provide for specific procedures.
A building visit allows the candidate to identify operational issues that are difficult to summarize. To better define the mandate, the board can review the financial, administrative and operational management services. It then becomes easier to require the same breakdown in each proposal.
Compare the scope of services, not just the total
Each proposal should be converted into an assessment grid. The board can assign a score to important elements and clearly indicate whether each task is included, optional or excluded. This method prevents a general description from being interpreted as a specific commitment.
| Item to compare | Questions to ask | Expected proof or details |
|---|---|---|
| Financial management | Who prepares the budget and collects common expenses? | List of reports, frequency and approval process |
| Administrative management | Who prepares notices, the AGM and the minutes? | Annual schedule and deliverable templates |
| Operations | How often are visits conducted? | Number of visits, reports and emergency procedure |
| Suppliers | How are work proposals obtained? | Authorization thresholds and disclosure of commercial relationships |
| Technology | Which documents are available online? | Portal demonstration, access rights and export options |
| Transition | Who retrieves the archives and banking access credentials? | Timeline, designated person and handover format |
Pay close attention to wording such as “board support” or “coordination as needed.” These phrases specify neither the amount included nor the usual timelines. A detailed schedule attached to the contract provides a more useful reference during the mandate.
The syndicate should also identify the person who will serve the building. It can ask about that person’s experience, approximate caseload and the procedure to be followed during absences. The page explaining how to hire a condo manager presents other useful criteria for this assessment.
Review fees, exclusions and financial mechanisms
The price should be converted to a common period and unit of measurement. The board should distinguish recurring fees from separately billed services. It can then estimate the annual cost based on the syndicate’s actual activities.
Variable items that often need clarification include additional meetings, major projects, collection files and the preparation of exceptional documents. Start-up, archiving and end-of-mandate fees should also be checked. A transparent proposal specifies the trigger, calculation method and authority required before any expense is incurred.
The comparison should also cover financial controls. The board can ask the following questions:
- Do the bank accounts remain in the syndicate’s name?
- Who can create, approve and modify a payment?
- Is dual authorization available for certain amounts?
- How often are bank reconciliations prepared?
- Does the board receive a comparative budget and a balance sheet?
- How are arrears of common expenses tracked?
These controls reduce ambiguity and make it easier for directors to exercise oversight. Separating roles becomes particularly important when several people can modify a supplier’s contact information. The procedures should be documented before access is granted.
Check the contract, qualifications and transition
The contract should reflect the commitments in the proposal, its term, renewal and termination conditions. It should also explain document retention, confidentiality, data access and the handover of archives. A simple sales presentation does not replace these clauses.
The Civil Code of Québec governs the administration of the syndicate and allows day-to-day management to be entrusted to a manager chosen by the board of directors, particularly under articles 1084 and 1085 C.C.Q. This delegation does not relieve directors of their duty to oversee the mandate. The contract should therefore provide for reports that are sufficiently clear to support their decisions.
The board can ask for references involving buildings with a comparable number of units and level of complexity. It should also verify relevant insurance coverage, personal information protection policies and complaint-handling mechanisms. The resources of the Regroupement des gestionnaires et copropriétaires du Québec can complement its review of co-ownership practices.
A manager generally coordinates suppliers rather than carrying out specialized work personally. When a contractor works on the building, the syndicate should use the RBQ tool to check the contractor’s licence when the work requires one. It should also determine who verifies insurance coverage, proposals and completion of the work.
Finally, the transition deserves a separate section in the proposal. It should cover contracts, keys, registers, digital access, insurance claim files and banking information. If the syndicate is already replacing a supplier, a plan for changing condo managers helps structure the steps and notice period.
Frequently asked questions about management proposals
How many proposals should the board request?
Three proposals generally provide a reasonable basis for comparison, without constituting a universal legal rule. The declaration of co-ownership or an internal policy may nevertheless require a specific procedure. The board should retain its assessment grid, the responses received and the resolution authorizing the contract.
Is the least expensive manager necessarily less comprehensive?
Not necessarily. The manager’s organization, technology and division of responsibilities can affect the rate. The board must nevertheless check exclusions, volume limits and variable fees. The predictable total cost is more revealing than the amount shown on its own.
Who should approve the choice of manager?
The board of directors normally chooses the manager within the scope of its powers, subject to the declaration of co-ownership and applicable decisions. The resolution should identify the candidate, term, fees and authorized signatories. The minutes must accurately reflect this decision.
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a lawyer or notary for advice about your situation.
Do you manage a co-ownership in Québec? View our rates or contact us to assess your needs.
