Challenging a Special Assessment in a Quebec Condo
A special assessment can represent a significant and unexpected expense for a co-owner. In a divided co-ownership, however, disagreeing with it does not automatically eliminate the obligation to pay.
As a general rule, a properly adopted assessment remains payable until it is cancelled, amended or settled with the syndicate. Withholding payment without following a structured process may therefore result in interest, collection costs and other consequences.
Before paying or challenging the assessment, you should review the declaration of co-ownership, known as the DCV, the board of directors’ decisions and the financial documents. The nature of the work and the authority that approved the expense are also decisive factors.
Do you have to pay a disputed special assessment?
The prudent answer is generally yes, unless an order, written agreement or appropriate legal opinion indicates otherwise. A written challenge will not usually suspend the due date stated in the assessment notice.
Contributions to common expenses are established under the rules of the Civil Code of Québec, including articles 1064, 1071 and 1072 C.C.Q. They may fund operating expenses, the contingency fund or work required for the common portions.
The board of directors must administer the building and ensure its preservation. Depending on the expense, it may adopt a budget and set contributions after consulting the assembly. Transformation, enlargement or improvement work may instead require a decision by the co-owners.
The name given to the invoice therefore does not settle the issue. You must determine whether the amount is a common expense, a contribution to the contingency fund or an expense requiring a specific vote.
Paying while reserving your rights may limit the risks associated with default without confirming that the decision is valid. However, the wording used and the strategy should be validated by a legal adviser.
What documents should you review before challenging the assessment?
An effective challenge is based on the syndicate’s documents, not only on the amount claimed. The co-owner should request a written explanation and review the documents available in the co-ownership register.
Here are the main elements to review:
- the DCV and its rules concerning common expenses, assessments and due dates;
- the budget adopted by the board of directors and presented to the co-owners;
- the minutes of the board of directors’ meeting or the relevant assembly;
- the notice of meeting and the resolutions adopted at the AGM or a special general meeting;
- the bids, contracts, technical reports and invoices related to the work;
- the contingency fund study and maintenance logbook;
- the allocation method based on the fractions or the beneficiaries of the limited common portions.
An assessment concerning a balcony, parking space or another component should be analysed using the DCV. It often specifies whether the element belongs to the common portions, private portions or limited common portions.
The co-owner should also check whether the syndicate followed its internal procedure. An error in sending the notice or an irregular time frame does not necessarily make the entire assessment null, but it may support a request for correction.
For the work, the permit and contractor’s licence can be checked with the Régie du bâtiment du Québec. The RGCQ also publishes general resources on governance and best practices in co-ownership.
Structured financial management makes it easier to retain decisions, budgets and supporting documents. It also helps the board of directors clearly explain how an assessment was calculated.
How should you properly challenge the decision?
The first step is to write to the syndicate promptly. The message should identify the assessment, give the specific grounds for the challenge and list the documents requested. A general statement that the amount is too high will rarely be sufficient.
It is preferable to distinguish between four types of issues:
| Possible reason | Useful verification | Possible action |
|---|---|---|
| Incorrect allocation | DCV, shares and nature of the expense | Request a recalculation |
| Insufficient authority of the board of directors | Resolution, budget and nature of the work | Request a review or legal opinion |
| Irregular procedure | Notice of meeting, quorum, vote and minutes | Raise the irregularity promptly |
| Unjustified expense | Bids, expert opinion and contract | Request the reasons and supporting documents |
The co-owner may request that their objection be recorded in the minutes of an assembly. They may also propose a resolution, request a meeting or use mediation when dialogue remains possible.
A decision of the assembly or the board of directors may sometimes be challenged before the court. Articles 1086 and following of the C.C.Q. provide for certain remedies when decisions are partial, made to cause harm or contrary to the rights of co-owners.
Strict time limits may apply, including a 90-day time limit in certain situations. You should therefore promptly consult a lawyer or notary rather than wait through several due dates.
A resource such as the OACIQ can provide information about relevant documents in a real estate transaction. However, it does not replace legal advice regarding the validity of an assessment.
What are the risks if you do not pay?
Non-payment often turns a legal disagreement into a collection problem. Depending on the DCV, the syndicate may claim interest and the costs permitted by the constituting documents or by law.
After three months of default concerning their contribution to common expenses, a co-owner may temporarily lose their right to vote. The syndicate may also commence legal proceedings and, when the conditions are met, publish a legal hypothec.
These steps can increase the balance owing and complicate a sale or refinancing. The notary and buyer will generally examine amounts owing, adopted assessments and disputes affecting the fraction.
Non-payment may also affect the syndicate’s cash flow. The other co-owners may then have to temporarily absorb a shortfall, even when the work concerns safety or preventive maintenance.
One option is to request a written payment schedule without acknowledging the validity of the disputed assessment. The board of directors is not necessarily required to accept it, but a documented proposal often encourages a more constructive discussion.
Frequently asked questions about special assessments
Can the board of directors impose an assessment without a vote at the AGM?
In many situations, the board of directors prepares the budget and sets contributions after consulting the assembly, without having each expense approved by vote. However, certain work or significant changes require specific authorization from the co-owners. The DCV and the exact nature of the project must be reviewed.
Can a co-owner pay under protest?
They may submit payment with a written reservation stating that they are maintaining their rights. This step does not guarantee that a remedy will be admissible and does not interrupt the applicable time limits. Legal advice can help tailor the wording to the situation.
Can you deduct an amount that the syndicate owes the co-owner?
A unilateral deduction is risky. The rules on set-off require, among other things, debts that are certain, liquid and due, and their application depends on the facts. It is preferable to obtain a written agreement or legal opinion before reducing condo fees or assessments.
In practice, challenging a special assessment in a Quebec condo requires prompt action, documenting every objection and respecting the deadlines. Payment and the challenge can proceed in parallel when rights are clearly reserved.
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a lawyer or notary regarding your situation.
Do you manage a condo in Quebec? Explore our packages or contact us to assess your needs.
