Insurance Claim Denied: Maintenance in a Co-ownership
A recurring roof leak, an expired water heater or deteriorated window seals can turn a loss into a major headache: the syndicate’s insurer refuses to provide coverage, citing neglected maintenance. In a divided co-ownership, responsibility for maintaining the common portions and private portions has a direct impact on the outcome of a claim. Since Bill 16 came into force, the maintenance logbook and EUC (maintenance logbook study) provide a framework for these obligations and for demonstrating the board of directors’ (the board’s) due diligence.
This article explains when and why an insurer may deny coverage, what Bill 16 requires regarding the maintenance logbook and EUC, how to document maintenance with supporting evidence (minutes, reports and invoices), and what to do if a claim is denied. The goal is to help your board reduce risks, protect coverage and better defend the syndicate.
Why an insurer may deny coverage
Multiperil insurance policies for syndicates cover fortuitous damage. They generally exclude normal wear and tear, corrosion, inherent defects and damage resulting from inadequate maintenance. In practice, a denial often occurs when the facts demonstrate foreseeable or repeated negligence.
Typical examples include:
- A water heater that has exceeded its recommended service life, with no preventive replacement policy.
- A roofing membrane that has reached the end of its service life, with no documented inspections or corrective maintenance.
- Rainwater drains and stacks that have not been cleaned, resulting in repeated backups.
- Exterior caulking that has been cracked for years, with water infiltration left untreated.
- A missing or unmaintained backwater valve, despite a history of backups.
In these situations, the insurer may cite a failure to fulfil the duty to maintain and reduce or deny the indemnity. The exact wording depends on the policy. Refer to your contract and keep a copy readily available to the board.
It should be noted that the declaration of co-ownership (DCV) and the building regulations allocate obligations between the syndicate and the co-owners. Failure to maintain a private portion that has caused damage to the common portions may also affect the settlement of the claim and internal recourse.
Useful reference: the RGCQ’s recommended insurance and co-ownership claim-management practices.
Bill 16: maintenance logbook, EUC and the board’s duties
Bill 16 amended the Civil Code of Québec to equip syndicates with the necessary tools: the maintenance logbook, maintenance planning and the contingency fund study are now structured around technical analyses and a documented roadmap. In brief:
- Maintenance logbook: the syndicate must maintain a living record describing the building’s components, their past and upcoming maintenance, and the recommended work.
- EUC (maintenance logbook study): a technical process that feeds into the logbook and specifies the frequency of inspections, preventive maintenance and replacements.
- Contingency fund study: this quantifies the replacement costs of components over the relevant horizon, so contributions can be adjusted and underfunding avoided.
These tools, which are required or governed by the provisions introduced by Bill 16 (see sections 1070.2 et seq. C.C.Q.), serve as evidence of due diligence if a loss occurs. An incomplete or unapplied logbook, or an EUC that is disregarded, strengthens an insurer’s argument that maintenance was neglected.
To consult the official texts:
- Civil Code of Québec – provisions applicable to syndicates of co-owners (see sections 1070.2 and following) on LégisQuébec.
- Bill 16 (S.Q. 2019, c. 28) on LégisQuébec.
- RBQ guidance on safe building maintenance and hiring licensed contractors: RBQ.
Proving your maintenance: supporting documents and traceability
When an insurer questions the syndicate’s due diligence, the quality of your records can make all the difference. Organize complete, chronological evidence:
- An up-to-date maintenance logbook (component inventory, completed maintenance and upcoming deadlines) and the related EUC.
- Inspection reports (roof, building envelope, indoor parking, mechanical systems), with dated photographs.
- Work orders and invoices from RBQ-licensed contractors, along with the contractor’s liability insurance certificate.
- Minutes of board and AGM meetings documenting maintenance decisions, adoption of the action plan and follow-up on recommendations.
- Notices and reminders sent to co-owners (e.g., replacing water heaters at 10 years and testing backwater valves), with proof of distribution.
- Correspondence with the property manager, experts and insurer (dates when the loss was reported, temporary measures and steps taken to prevent further damage).
Practical tip: in the DCV, check the clauses governing access to private portions for essential inspections (e.g., risers and shut-off valves). The board must ensure that co-owners comply with the prescribed maintenance rules, particularly when the condition of a private-portion component could cause damage to the common portions.
Useful resource for verifying a contractor: the RBQ website provides information about licences and compliance.
Preventing a denial: an action plan for the board
An insurer assesses both the loss and the syndicate’s maintenance culture. Here is a practical plan to reduce denials and limit recurring deductibles:
- Update the EUC and maintenance logbook, then prioritize critical work (roofing, waterproofing, common plumbing, fire safety).
- Adopt a written preventive replacement policy (water heaters, backwater valves, detectors and window seals) with a schedule, responsibilities and sanctions provided for in the building regulations.
- Budget for the work in the multi-year plan and adjust condo fee contributions based on the contingency fund study. If necessary, plan a resolution for the AGM and communicate the impact on common expenses early.
- Arrange periodic inspections by qualified professionals and RBQ-licensed contractors, and keep all certificates.
- Standardize documentation: work-order templates, meeting-minute templates for maintenance follow-up and a register of notices to co-owners.
- Review the policy annually with your broker; confirm specific maintenance requirements (e.g., water-heater replacement) and exclusions.
To structure this work, see our Services pages:
- Operations management (maintenance and claims): multiRent – Services, operations management
- Financial management (budgets, contributions and contingency fund): multiRent – Services, financial management
- For more practical articles, consult the multiRent blog index.
Anonymized real-life case: a syndicate we assist adopted a policy of replacing water heaters at 10 years, documented in the logbook and approved at the AGM. When water damage was caused by a unit that was still within its useful life, the insurer acknowledged the preventive measures and compliance with the technical recommendations. The claim proceeded without questioning whether maintenance had been neglected.
Denied insurance claim: steps for responding effectively
If you receive a denial, avoid improvised discussions. Follow an orderly process:
- Request the reason in writing, including the policy clauses relied on and the factual issues alleged.
- Gather your maintenance evidence: logbook extracts, reports, invoices, relevant minutes, photographs and communications.
- Check how responsibilities are allocated in the DCV and building regulations (common portions versus private portions) so that you can correctly identify the cause and internal recourse.
- If necessary, obtain a technical opinion (from an engineer or architect) confirming the condition of the components at the time of the loss and the compliance of the maintenance work.
- Send the insurer a structured, point-by-point response with your supporting documents. Document any mitigation measures taken immediately after the loss to prevent further damage.
- If the matter reaches an impasse, consider a formal demand and private dispute-resolution methods. The Civil Code governs insurance obligations and contractual good faith; obtain professional assistance (see the C.C.Q.).
Official resources on the legal framework and recommended practices:
- Civil Code of Québec – LégisQuébec
- Bill 16 (S.Q. 2019, c. 28) – LégisQuébec
- RBQ – Building maintenance and safety
- RGCQ – Co-ownership resources
FAQ
Can an insurer deny a claim if the loss results from a construction defect?
Construction defects are often excluded or handled differently depending on the policy. An insurer may decline coverage if the root cause is an excluded defect. However, diligent maintenance and any action taken against the responsible parties, if necessary, should be documented to preserve your rights.
Is preventive replacement of water heaters mandatory?
There is no single age imposed by law. However, several policies and insurers recommend replacement by a specific time, often 10 years. Incorporate a clear policy into the building regulations, record it in the maintenance logbook and notify co-owners in writing.
How does Bill 16 protect our syndicate during a claim?
Bill 16 strengthens planning and traceability. An up-to-date maintenance logbook and EUC, supported by a contingency fund study, demonstrate the board’s due diligence. This evidence reduces the risk that an insurer will characterize the situation as neglected maintenance.
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a lawyer or notary regarding your situation.
Do you manage a co-ownership in Quebec? Discover our packages or contact us to assess your needs.
