Cumulative Voting in Québec Co-ownership: Is It Permitted?
“Cumulative voting” is often discussed in corporate law when electing directors. In divided co-ownership, the question sometimes comes up at the AGM: can you pool your votes to support a candidate for the board of directors? In Québec, the basic rule remains that decisions are made according to the voting rights attached to each co-ownership fraction and the majorities provided for in the Civil Code of Québec (C.C.Q.). Let’s look at what the law and your declaration of co-ownership actually permit, and how to organize a board of directors election without disputes.
What exactly is cumulative voting?
Under cumulative voting, someone who holds, for example, 5 votes to elect 3 directors could assign all 5 votes to a single candidate. This mechanism is intended to allow a united minority to elect at least one representative. In co-ownership, some co-owners see it as a way to better represent specific interests (e.g., a tower, a type of unit or a sensitive issue).
However, an AGM of a syndicate of co-owners does not function like a shareholders’ meeting. The usual practice in Québec remains voting by ballot (often by secret ballot), with each co-owner exercising voting rights corresponding to the relative value of their fraction, as indicated in the declaration of co-ownership. Proxies remain permitted under the applicable rules, but they are not equivalent to cumulative voting.
What does the Civil Code of Québec say?
The C.C.Q. governs co-ownership by fractions, meetings and the election of the board of directors. Generally, decisions are made by a majority of the votes of the co-owners present or represented, and voting rights correspond to the relative value of each fraction as provided in the declaration of co-ownership. Certain decisions require higher qualified majorities.
No provision of the C.C.Q. expressly authorizes cumulative voting for the election of directors of the syndicate. On the contrary, the legal framework is based on the principle of the relative value of fractions and on majorities determined according to the nature of the decision. Introducing cumulative voting would alter the balance of representation provided for by law and could be considered incompatible with these rules.
- Text of the Civil Code of Québec (co-ownership): LégisQuébec – CCQ-1991
- Majorities and decisions at meetings (see the provisions on co-ownership by fractions): Section 1090 C.C.Q.
In practice, the courts and legal scholars point out that clauses or practices that contravene mandatory provisions of the C.C.Q. have no effect. Therefore, even if the intention is to increase representativeness, cumulative voting is generally not accepted in co-ownership in Québec.
Can your declaration of co-ownership and building by-laws require it?
The declaration of co-ownership and building by-laws can specify various procedures for holding meetings and electing the board of directors (e.g., number of seats, term lengths and secret ballots). However, they cannot contradict mandatory provisions of the C.C.Q. A clause establishing cumulative voting could be declared invalid if it alters the legal system of representation based on relative value or the majorities provided for by law.
Before adopting such a rule, it is advisable to obtain an independent legal opinion. If in doubt, maintain mechanisms that comply with the C.C.Q. to avoid challenges, the annulment of an election or litigation-related costs.
- AGM and governance best practices (industry reference): RGCQ
Best practices for electing the board without cumulative voting
Even without cumulative voting, you can improve the fairness and transparency of the board election:
- Prepare a clear notice of meeting, with an agenda that mentions “Election of directors” and the voting method provided for in the declaration of co-ownership.
- Collect nominations before the AGM and allow nominations from the floor, with a short and equitable presentation period for each candidate.
- Use a secret ballot when the situation is tense, and appoint independent scrutineers to count the votes.
- Review the voting rules: rights proportionate to the relative value of the fraction, valid proxies and quorum verification at the beginning of the meeting.
- Clearly document the results in the minutes: number of seats, elected candidates, term lengths and any challenge raised.
- Make candidates aware of directors’ duties and priorities (budget, common expenses, contingency fund, maintenance logbook/EUC), so that the election focuses on management rather than personal issues.
Need a hand organizing a compliant AGM, preparing the documents and holding a smooth vote? See our administrative management services and explore more resources on our blog.
What should you do if someone requests cumulative voting at the AGM?
- Calmly explain what the C.C.Q. and the declaration of co-ownership provide, and why cumulative voting does not apply in co-ownership.
- Propose compliant alternatives: electing directors one position at a time to clarify the choices, ensuring equitable presentations by candidates, using a secret ballot or creating advisory committees.
- If the request persists, invite the meeting to mandate the board of directors to consult a legal professional and, if necessary, propose adjustments to the declaration of co-ownership that remain compatible with the law (without introducing vote pooling).
- Record the request and the response in the minutes to preserve a clear record in case of a subsequent challenge.
To verify the legal basis, refer directly to the Civil Code of Québec and industry documentation:
- Civil Code of Québec – LégisQuébec
- Regroupement des gestionnaires et copropriétaires du Québec (RGCQ)
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice. For your situation, consult a lawyer or notary.
Do you manage a co-ownership in Québec? Discover our packages or contact us to assess your needs.
