Proxy Voting on a Condo Board of Directors
Can an absent board member give their proxy to a colleague to vote on the board of directors? In divided co-ownership in Quebec, the answer is generally no. The position of board member is personal in nature, which distinguishes it from a co-owner’s right to vote at the AGM.
This distinction affects quorum, the validity of resolutions and the drafting of the minutes. It becomes particularly important when the board must approve a budget, urgent work or a special assessment. Here are the rules to understand before accepting a proxy during a board meeting.
The short answer: a board member must vote personally
A board member should not delegate their vote to another board member. They were elected or appointed to personally exercise their judgment, take part in deliberations and act in the syndicate’s interest. A proxy therefore does not allow a colleague to replace them as a board member in attendance.
The syndicate of co-owners is a legal person under section 1039 of the Civil Code of Québec. Board members act as mandataries of this legal person and must comply with their duties of prudence, diligence, honesty and loyalty. These principles arise in particular from sections 321 and 322 of the Civil Code of Québec.
Section 336 C.C.Q. provides that board decisions are made by a majority of the votes of the board members. This rule applies to board members who validly participate in the decision, not to votes transferred by proxy. The declaration of co-ownership and the building’s by-laws must also be consulted, particularly to determine quorum and the notice requirements.
An internal provision should not be interpreted as allowing a board member to circumvent their personal responsibilities. If a provision is ambiguous, the syndicate should obtain legal advice tailored to its situation.
Why is a proxy problematic on the board?
The board of directors’ work is not limited to recording votes. Board members must review the information, ask questions and consider the discussions that take place during the meeting. This responsibility is difficult to reconcile with an instruction given to a colleague in advance.
A board member must also assess the syndicate’s interests at the time the decision is made. Circumstances may change after a purported proxy is signed. A contractor may modify their proposal, a conflict of interest may be disclosed or an unforeseen expense may come to light.
A proxy should not be used to artificially meet quorum requirements. If the by-laws require a majority of board members to be present, an absent person does not become present simply because they have sent their instructions. A decision made without quorum could subsequently be challenged.
The same principle applies to financial and operational matters. These may include the budget, condo fees, common expenses, assessments or the contingency fund. It also applies to the maintenance logbook, the contingency fund study, the EFF and work affecting the common portions or private portions.
Board members can consult the resources of the Regroupement des gestionnaires et copropriétaires du Québec to learn more about governance practices. The OACIQ also provides general information about divided co-ownership, which is particularly useful during a transaction.
AGM and board meeting: two different voting rights
The confusion often comes from the rules that apply to a meeting of co-owners. At an AGM, a co-owner may generally be represented by a mandatary, subject to the declaration of co-ownership and the applicable legal rules. The mandatary then exercises the rights attached to the represented fractions.
At a board meeting, participants instead exercise the functions arising from their position. A board member who is also a co-owner therefore wears two distinct hats. A proxy that is valid for the meeting of co-owners does not allow them to delegate their position on the board.
| Situation | Is a proxy generally possible? | Practical consequence |
|---|---|---|
| A co-owner’s vote at the AGM | Yes, subject to the applicable rules | The mandatary votes for the represented fractions |
| A board member’s vote at a board meeting | No | The board member must participate personally |
| Virtual attendance at a board meeting | Often possible, depending on the applicable rules | Participation must allow for genuine exchanges |
| Written instructions sent to a colleague | No, as a substitute for voting | The instructions create neither presence nor an additional voting right |
| Written board resolution | Must be verified according to the declaration of co-ownership and the applicable framework | The validity requirements must be met |
Remote participation is not a proxy. Where the applicable framework allows it, a board member may take part in the meeting by telephone or videoconference. They remain present, hear the discussions and cast their own vote.
The declaration of co-ownership may provide for additional rules concerning meetings, notices and technological means. These provisions must be read together with the Civil Code, rather than in isolation. Structured administrative management makes this verification easier before each meeting.
What should be done when a board member cannot participate?
The president or secretary should first check whether the meeting still has quorum without the absent board member. If not, the board should normally postpone the meeting, unless an emergency requires another permitted course of action. A proxy should not be counted among those present.
When remote participation is authorized, it is often the simplest option. The board member must be able to follow the discussions continuously, speak and vote personally. The minutes should specify the communication method used and confirm that person’s participation.
Before the meeting, the board can follow these steps:
- Review the declaration of co-ownership and the building’s by-laws concerning quorum, notices and remote meetings.
- Confirm which board members will participate personally, either in person or by an authorized technological means.
- Distribute the documents sufficiently in advance to support an informed decision.
- Disclose and address any conflict of interest before the vote in question.
- Record the attendance, abstentions, dissents and outcome of each resolution in the minutes.
If quorum is not met, the minutes should record the lack of quorum. Those present may sometimes discuss matters informally, but they should not present these discussions as valid board decisions. A new notice can then be sent in accordance with the declaration of co-ownership.
For urgent decisions, the board should verify the mechanisms actually available rather than improvising a proxy. Depending on the governing documents and the circumstances, a virtual meeting or written resolution could be considered. A complex question nevertheless warrants legal validation before adoption.
The syndicate also benefits from retaining notices, documents reviewed and signed versions of resolutions. This practice supports administrative continuity and facilitates the work of future board members. Other practical resources are available on the multiRent blog.
Frequently asked questions about proxy voting on the board
Can a board member give voting instructions to a colleague?
They may communicate their opinion, but this communication does not replace their participation. The colleague retains their own duty to exercise judgment and does not receive an additional vote. The absent board member must not be counted toward quorum or among those voting.
Can the declaration of co-ownership expressly authorize a proxy on the board?
Such a provision must be examined carefully in light of the Civil Code and the personal nature of the position. The board should not assume that it allows the complete delegation of responsibilities. A lawyer or notary can determine its scope and validity.
Can a co-owner who is also a board member use a proxy at the AGM?
Yes, they may receive or give a proxy as a co-owner where the applicable rules allow it. They are then acting in the context of the meeting of co-owners, not as a board member. The powers, quorum and calculation of votes are not the same as those applicable to the board.
In practice, proxy voting on the board of directors of a condominium should not be used to replace an absent board member. Personal participation, including remotely where permitted, better protects the quality and validity of the decision-making process. Properly applying the declaration of co-ownership and keeping detailed minutes also reduces the risk of a challenge.
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a lawyer or notary regarding your situation.
Do you manage a condominium in Quebec? Explore our plans or contact us to assess your needs.
