Condo Cameras: Providing Footage to Police (Bill 25)
Installing cameras in a divided co-ownership is common in Montréal to secure the common portions. But when police request recordings, what does Bill 25 actually allow? Balancing the right to privacy with the duty to protect the building, the board of directors must act methodically. Here is a practical guide to when, how and under what conditions footage may be provided, without putting the syndicate in breach.
What Bill 25 Changes for Condo Cameras
Bill 25 modernizes the Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector. Video footage in which a person is identifiable constitutes personal information. For a syndicate of co-owners, this notably means:
- Designating a person responsible for the protection of personal information (often a board member or the manager) and publishing their contact information if you have a website.
- Defining a legitimate and specific purpose for the cameras (e.g., preventing vandalism), documented in a policy approved by the board.
- Minimizing collection: limiting angles to the necessary common portions (not recording balconies or interiors), with proportionate resolution and retention periods.
- Informing people through clear signage at entrances and near filmed areas: the presence of cameras, their purpose and the responsible person’s contact information.
- Controlling access: maintaining a consultation log, authorizations and confidentiality agreements with the supplier or concierge.
- Managing privacy incidents and documenting all external disclosures (including providing footage to police) in a register.
These obligations are in addition to the syndicate’s responsibilities under the Civil Code of Québec (preserving the building, the building regulations and maintaining records). They apply equally to the board and the appointed manager.
Legal Basis: Privacy, the Syndicate and the Board’s Roles
The syndicate must reconcile two legal frameworks:
- Civil Code of Québec: the syndicate’s purpose is to preserve the building and administer the common portions (see section 1039 C.C.Q.). It adopts building regulations governing the security and use of the common portions (see section 1070 C.C.Q.). It maintains records and keeps relevant documents (minutes, policies and contracts; see sections 1070 and 342 C.C.Q., by analogy with the record-keeping requirements for legal persons).
- Bill 25 and the Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector (P-39.1): these govern the collection, use, retention and disclosure of personal information, including camera footage.
In practice, the board may authorize cameras for security purposes if the measure is proportionate and documented. Disclosing footage to third parties, including police services, must be based on a legal provision in the Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector and comply with the stated purpose.
For reference:
- Civil Code of Québec: framework governing the syndicate’s powers and the building regulations.
- Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector (P-39.1): rules governing disclosure without consent, privacy incidents and governance.
- Bill 25 (2021, c. 25): modernization legislation that notably amends P-39.1.
Useful links:
- Civil Code of Québec (CCQ-1991): https://www.legisquebec.gouv.qc.ca/fr/document/lc/CCQ-1991
- Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector (P-39.1): https://www.legisquebec.gouv.qc.ca/fr/document/lc/P-39.1
- Bill 25 (S.Q. 2021, c. 25): https://www.legisquebec.gouv.qc.ca/fr/Chapitres/lq/2021/c25
When and How to Provide Footage to Police
Footage may be provided to police without the consent of the people filmed in specific situations provided for under the Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector, including:
- Upon presentation of a document authorizing the request: a search warrant, court order or written request based on a legal power.
- In a serious emergency endangering a person’s life, health or safety, when there is not enough time to obtain formal authorization.
- When disclosure is clearly necessary to prevent, detect or suppress an offence and is requested by a person or organization authorized by law (to be interpreted restrictively; when in doubt, require a written legal basis).
Conversely, an investigator’s informal visit “to look at the cameras” without a warrant or emergency will generally not be sufficient. The board may politely refuse and invite the police to submit a written request or obtain the required document.
Recommended procedure when police make a request:
- Verify the identity and capacity of the requesting person. Ask for identification and their badge number.
- Require the written legal basis (warrant, order or request citing the applicable section) and keep a copy in the records.
- Record the request in the access log: date and time, person, reason, legal basis and segments requested.
- Limit the disclosure to what is strictly necessary: camera(s), time period and area. Do not provide entire days if a specific hour is sufficient.
- Produce a secure copy of the excerpts (ideally time-stamped), without altering the originals. If possible, mask irrelevant third parties.
- Transfer the files using a secure method (encrypted USB drive or secure portal) and document the handover (receipt, signature or file number).
- Notify your person responsible for the protection of personal information and maintain traceability.
Without a warrant or emergency, you can:
- Ask police to specify the purpose and section of the law being invoked.
- Suggest that an order or warrant be obtained.
- Offer to temporarily preserve the identified segments, in accordance with your retention policy, while awaiting the official document.
Internal Process: Policy, Access Log and Retention
To be ready when the police come knocking, adopt a clear internal policy, annexed to the building regulations or referenced in the declaration of co-ownership. It should cover:
- The cameras’ purposes and locations approved by the board (with supporting plans).
- Roles and responsibilities: board, manager, concierge and IT supplier.
- Access procedures: who may view footage, with which authorizations, and mandatory logging.
- Procedure for disclosing footage to third parties (including police): steps, approvals, minimization, masking and chain of custody.
- Retention and destruction: proportionate periods (from several days to several weeks depending on the risk), automatic purging, exceptions in the event of an investigation, and recording of preservation holds.
- Information security: passwords, encryption, storage in Québec, backups, testing and periodic audits.
- Privacy incident register: description, measures taken, risk assessment and required notifications, where applicable.
Operational best practices:
- Post notices about the presence of cameras at all entrances, indicating the purpose and the responsible person’s email address.
- Avoid filming private portions and sensitive areas (e.g., windows looking directly into a condo’s interior).
- Test footage retrieval every quarter to verify time stamps and quality.
- Set contractual requirements for the supplier (hosting and subcontractors), with clauses compliant with Bill 25.
- Budget for secure retention and masking costs as needed; approve these expenses at the AGM if necessary.
For installation and maintenance, remember that wiring and connections may need to be handled by contractors holding the appropriate licences. See the RBQ’s electrical requirements.
Common Scenarios and Mistakes to Avoid
Typical scenarios:
- Package theft in the entrance lobby: police request a specific time. Prepare a targeted excerpt and a handover receipt.
- Vandalism in the garage: you do not have a clear angle. Preserve the relevant time period and invite police to obtain a warrant if they want a broader range of hours.
- Dispute between co-owners: one demands a copy “for their file.” Treat this as a request for access to their personal information; verify their identity, extract only footage in which they are identifiable, mask third parties if possible, and apply the exceptions if access would interfere with an investigation.
Mistakes to avoid:
- Providing entire days of footage without a sufficient legal basis and without minimization.
- Giving an unauthorized person (including an outside agent) unlimited system access without logging.
- Retaining footage improperly “just in case,” beyond your established period.
- Forgetting to notify your responsible person and record the disclosure in the register.
- Filming private portions or areas beyond the stated purpose.
A Co-owner’s Access Rights and Exceptions
A co-owner may request access to personal information concerning them, including footage in which they are identifiable. The board must:
- Verify the applicant’s identity first.
- Search only the relevant segments and, where reasonable, mask identifiable third parties.
- Respond within the time limit set out in the Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector (subject to the exceptions), and give reasons for any partial or complete refusal.
Common exceptions include refusing or deferring access if disclosure reveals information about a non-consenting third party, breaches a confidential secret or risks interfering with an ongoing investigation. Document your analysis and inform the applicant of possible remedies.
Express Procedure Template for the Board
- Receive the request (from police or a private individual) and time-stamp it.
- Identify the legal basis: warrant/order, emergency or the individual’s access right.
- Apply minimization: time period, cameras and masking of third parties where reasonable.
- Have a designated person (the person responsible for personal information or a board officer) authorize the disclosure.
- Provide the footage through a secure channel and obtain proof of receipt.
- Record the transaction in the register and keep the documentation in the syndicate’s file.
Resources and Support
- Visit our Services page to see how we structure administrative management and record-keeping for co-ownerships: Services – administrative management.
- Compare our management packages for syndicates in the Greater Montréal area: multiRent packages.
- Explore other articles and legal updates on our blog.
- For a complex or urgent situation, contact us.
Useful external references:
- Civil Code of Québec (CCQ-1991) — the syndicate’s powers and building regulations: LégisQuébec
- Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector (P-39.1) — collection and disclosure of personal information: LégisQuébec
- Bill 25 — modernization of personal information protection: LégisQuébec
- Electrical work and qualifications (system installation): RBQ
FAQ
Q1. Can police require footage without a warrant?
Generally, no, except in a serious emergency or where another express legal basis applies. Always request a written request citing the power being invoked, or a warrant/order. In an emergency, limit the disclosure to what is strictly necessary and record everything.
Q2. How long should recordings be retained?
Bill 25 requires proportionality: keep recordings only as long as necessary for the purpose (security). Many syndicates choose several days or weeks depending on the risk and storage capacity, with exceptions where an incident requires a preservation hold. Decide this in your policy and apply it.
Q3. Can a co-owner obtain a copy showing them?
Yes, if they are identifiable, subject to exceptions (identifiable third parties, an ongoing investigation or sensitive information). Verify their identity, make a targeted extraction and mask third parties where reasonable. Give reasons for any partial refusal and indicate the available remedies.
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a lawyer or notary regarding your situation.
Do you manage a co-ownership in Québec? Explore our packages or contact us to assess your needs.
